Ninjahire LogoNinjahire
Recruitment Operations

What Is Direct Hire? How It Differs from Contract and Temp-to-Perm

In a direct hire engagement, a staffing agency finds and presents candidates for a permanent position. If the client hires one, the worker joins the client's payroll directly — the agency is never the employer of record. The agency earns a placement fee rather than an ongoing bill rate.

5 min read·Updated 2026-11-13

How Direct Hire Differs from Contract and Temp-to-Perm

ModelEmployer of recordAgency earnsConversion needed?
Direct hireClient, from day oneOne-time placement feeNo — permanent from start
Contract staffingAgencyBill rate markup over contract durationNot applicable
Contract-to-hireAgency, then client after conversionBill rate + conversion feeYes, at end of evaluation period

The Direct Hire Process

  1. Intake. The client and recruiter define the role, required qualifications, compensation range, and timeline. A thorough intake reduces wasted submissions.
  2. Search and sourcing. The agency searches its network, databases, and referral pipeline for qualified candidates.
  3. Screening and qualification. The agency screens candidates and presents a shortlist with assessments.
  4. Client interviews. The client interviews the shortlisted candidates.
  5. Offer and close. The client extends an offer; the agency may assist with negotiation.
  6. Placement and fee. The candidate starts; the client pays the placement fee — typically after a defined start or guarantee period.

Fee Structures: Contingency vs. Retained

Contingency search: The agency is paid only if its candidate is hired. Fees are typically a percentage of the placed candidate's first-year base salary. The client can work with multiple agencies simultaneously and owes a fee only to the one whose candidate is hired.

Retained search: The client pays a portion of the fee upfront, with the balance on completion. The agency commits exclusive effort to the search. Retained arrangements are common for senior, specialised, or confidential roles where the agency invests significantly more time and market coverage.

Fee percentages vary by agency, role seniority, and market. Clients should confirm the fee structure, guarantee period (the window in which the agency will re-recruit at no additional fee if the hire does not work out), and payment terms before engaging.

When Direct Hire Makes Sense

Direct hire is typically appropriate when the headcount is confirmed and budgeted, the role is long-term, and the organisation wants to bring someone onto its own payroll from the start. It avoids the billing overhead of contract staffing and the ambiguity of a temp-to-perm arrangement.

For senior or hard-to-fill roles where the talent pool is narrow and the search requires significant market coverage, retained search adds accountability and usually delivers faster access to passive candidates.

Questions to Ask a Direct Hire Recruiter

  • What is your fee structure, and when is payment triggered?
  • What is the guarantee period if the hire does not work out?
  • How many candidates will you present, and what is your typical submittal-to-interview ratio for similar roles?
  • Are you working this role exclusively, or concurrently with other clients?
  • What sourcing channels will you use beyond your existing database?

Frequently Asked Questions

What is a contingency fee in direct hire?▾
A contingency fee is a placement fee paid to the agency only if its candidate is hired. It is typically calculated as a percentage of the placed candidate's first-year base salary. The percentage varies by agency, role type, and market; clients should confirm the rate before the search begins.
What is a retained search?▾
A retained search is an exclusive search engagement where the client pays a portion of the fee upfront, committing to work with one agency for the assignment. The balance is paid on completion. Retained arrangements are common for senior, specialised, or confidential roles that require dedicated recruiter effort and broader market coverage.
Can you cancel a direct hire engagement?▾
In a contingency arrangement, the client can typically disengage at any time before a hire is made without owing a fee (though contract terms vary). In a retained arrangement, the upfront payment is usually non-refundable. Clients should review the engagement letter for cancellation terms, exclusivity periods, and what happens if the search is put on hold.

Try AI Recruiting Free

Source, screen, and book interviews automatically.

Start free trial