Ninjahire LogoNinjahire
AI Recruiting

Four-Fifths Rule

The four-fifths rule states that if a protected group's selection rate falls below 80% of the rate of the most-selected group, adverse impact is indicated in a selection procedure. It is a rule of thumb from the EEOC Uniform Guidelines, not a definitive legal standard.

5 min read·Updated 2026-11-13

What is the four-fifths rule?

The four-fifths rule (also called the 80% rule) is a rule of thumb from the EEOC's Uniform Guidelines on Employee Selection Procedures (29 CFR Part 1607, 1978). It states:

A selection rate for any race, sex, or ethnic group which is less than four-fifths (4/5) or eighty percent (80%) of the rate for the group with the highest rate will generally be regarded by the Federal enforcement agencies as evidence of adverse impact.

It is used to flag potential adverse impact for further investigation — not to prove or disprove discrimination as a matter of law.

How to apply the four-fifths rule

To apply the rule:

  1. Calculate the selection rate for each group: selections ÷ applicants
  2. Identify the group with the highest selection rate
  3. Divide each other group's selection rate by the highest rate
  4. If any ratio falls below 0.80 (80%), adverse impact is indicated

Example: 50 of 100 white applicants are selected (50%), and 20 of 60 Black applicants are selected (33%). The ratio is 33% ÷ 50% = 0.66, which is below 0.80 — adverse impact is indicated.

Limitations of the four-fifths rule

The rule has known limitations that courts and regulators acknowledge:

  • Small samples: With small applicant pools, random variation can easily produce a ratio below 0.80 without any real pattern of discrimination.
  • Not a legal bright line: Courts do not treat the rule as conclusive. Statistical significance testing (e.g., standard deviation analysis) is typically used alongside the four-fifths calculation.
  • Direction only: A ratio at or above 0.80 does not prove absence of adverse impact — a small practical difference may still be legally significant in other circumstances.

Practical use in AI hiring contexts

Employers using AI screening tools should run four-fifths analyses at each selection stage — application screening, resume scoring, interview shortlisting, and final selection — across protected demographic categories. When adverse impact is indicated:

  • Investigate the contributing features or model logic
  • Document the job-relatedness of the selection criteria
  • Consult employment counsel and an I-O psychologist
  • Consider whether a less discriminatory alternative achieves the same business objective

Frequently Asked Questions

Is the four-fifths rule the only test for adverse impact?▾
No. Courts and the EEOC also use statistical significance tests (such as standard deviation analysis or chi-square tests). The four-fifths rule is a screening tool, not a definitive legal standard. Both practical and statistical significance are considered.
Does the rule apply to AI-assisted screening?▾
Yes. Any selection procedure — including AI-based tools — that substantially assists employment decisions is subject to the same adverse impact analysis framework under the Uniform Guidelines.
What counts as the "selection" event for calculating the rate?▾
Each stage that substantially limits the pool of candidates can be an independent selection event: initial screening, interview, final offer. Adverse impact should be evaluated at each stage, not just the end of the process.

Try AI Recruiting Free

Source, screen, and book interviews automatically.

Start free trial