How to Source Candidates
Sourcing is the highest-leverage skill in recruiting — the quality of your pipeline determines the quality of every hire downstream. This guide walks through the practical process from profile definition to outreach, with guidance on where AI fits.
Step 1: Build a Precise Ideal Candidate Profile
Vague requirements produce unusable candidate lists. Before opening any sourcing tool, get alignment with the hiring manager on exactly what "qualified" means for this role:
- Must-have skills — the 3–5 technical or functional skills without which the candidate cannot do the job. Not the nice-to-haves.
- Experience level — years of experience in a specific area, not just overall tenure.
- Industry background — does it matter whether they've worked in fintech vs. healthtech? Be specific.
- Location and work arrangement — remote, hybrid, or in-office. This filters out candidates who won't accept the offer.
- Compensation range — knowing the budget before sourcing saves everyone time. Don't source $200K candidates for a $130K role.
Step 2: Search Your ATS Before Going External
Your ATS likely contains years of past applicants, silver medalists, and candidates who expressed interest but weren't right for the role at the time. These people already know your company and have been pre-screened to some degree.
Searching your ATS first is faster, cheaper, and often produces higher-quality candidates than cold external sourcing. Most ATSs have basic search; AI-powered rediscovery tools (like Ninjahire's) can resurface candidates who match your current criteria even when they were originally screened for a different role.
Step 3: Build an External Target List
Once your ATS is exhausted, go external. Depending on the role:
- LinkedIn Recruiter for professional and executive roles
- GitHub, Stack Overflow, or technical portfolio sites for engineering roles
- Indeed and ZipRecruiter resume databases for high-volume roles
- Dribbble or Behance for design roles
- Industry-specific job boards and communities for niche specialisations
Build a list of 50–100 candidates before you start outreach. Quality of targeting matters more than list size — 50 well-matched candidates outperform 500 loosely matched ones.
Step 4: Write Outreach That Gets Replies
The message is the bottleneck. A strong candidate list produces zero results if nobody replies. The fundamentals of effective sourcing outreach:
- Reference something specific from their background in the opening line
- State the role, company, and one compelling reason to pay attention — comp range, interesting problem, growth trajectory
- Keep it under 150 words
- End with a low-friction ask: "Would a quick call make sense?" not "Apply at the link below"
Send 2–3 follow-ups over 2 weeks. Most replies come from follow-up messages, not the first touch.
Step 5: Use AI to Scale What Works
Once you've validated which message angles and channels work for a role, AI sourcing tools let you scale the approach without proportional time investment. AI agents can search your ATS and external databases simultaneously, rank candidates by match quality, generate personalised outreach for each candidate, and run multi-channel follow-up sequences.
The sourcer's focus shifts from manual execution to quality review — checking the AI's candidate selections, approving outreach, and handling interested replies. Volume goes up; time per candidate goes down.